Amaranthine18 wrote:Mr.X wrote: After the disaster that were Headlines, Voodoo and Song for Her, I only really care for a new compilation with some unreleased tracks at this stage.
Are you trying to say that the unreleased tracks are better than Headlines, Voodoo and Song For Her? The girls even admitted that those songs that didn't make it to the album because they are not good enough. Melanie C said that the one of the songs such as "C U next Tuesday" is a "shit".
That means those songs are even worse than their released B-sides. If you think that Bumper to Bumper, Spice Invaders etc.. are better than Headlines, Voodoo and Song For Her then I rest my case.
For me, those songs should remain in the vault.
None of that makes sense. Why would I care what another person says about a song when it's subjective. Just because Melanie says something is shit doesn't mean it is, look at her albums. She's released songs that I think are shit but she thought otherwise to release. For all we know, some of those songs could be their best. An example for myself is 'Give You What You Want'; that's one of my favorites of theirs, above majority of their released material, yet that should have stayed in a vault according to you. No thanks, I'm glad it's not in a 'vault'.