sammy01 wrote:I think everyone is over reacting, I think at worst it is a 3 piece track recorded for the Ab Fab soundtrack. Eliot tweeted about 20 years, then tweeted he was doing a lot of things 20 years ago. Then when Mel B let the cat out the bag and the pap pics came out he pretty much confirmed it. He then tweets the words 'ab-fab' when referring to their 2nd stint in the studio and to me that wasn't coincidence even if he then straight away again claimed it wasn't.
Eliot has a big mouth and has to keep back tracking to me.
If it is a 3 piece bonus song under the name of the spice girls for a sound track then bring it on. If the tour is still 4 piece then all is good.
I personally think we will get a mixture of 3/4/5 piece stuff this reunion. They will probably all do as much as their schedules will allow, which for Mel C probably meant she couldn't do the soundtrack song but seen as it is just an extra for the reunion it is all good.
Think we might get a 5 piece interview or photoshoot or documentary so Posh has done her bit and a 4 piece tour.
This is exactly what I've been thinking Sammy re the new song. I think (assume) it is for Ab Fab and only features the three girls. I just can't think that Melanie wouldn't be there for the recording if she really was a part of it. If this is the case, I really don't mind. It's these three girls that I want to hear the most as we've been waiting on new solo music from them forever (in comparison to Melanie who has obviously released so much more). Completely biased but it's Emma's voice which is always the key ingredient to any Spice song, so her plus Mel and Geri still have huge potential to make this brilliant. Though it will still be a shame and bizarre if Melanie has chosen not to do it.
As for touring I really think they need Melanie onboard.